MicroStrategy Faces Mounting Pressure from Potential Index Exclusion

A fundamental debate among major index providers has unexpectedly placed MicroStrategy at its center. MSCI Inc. is currently reviewing whether companies holding extremely large cryptocurrency balances should be removed from its core benchmarks—a policy that directly targets MicroStrategy's primary business strategy. Such a move could trigger billions in forced selling by passive funds, adding further strain to the stock's already lackluster performance.

The uncertainty stems from a new MSCI consultation paper focusing on "Index Purity." The global index giant is considering excluding firms whose balance sheets consist of more than 50% digital assets. This criterion would effectively target equities that function as proxies for direct Bitcoin investment.

MicroStrategy would be immediately impacted by such a rule. For years, the company has leveraged its corporate treasury to accumulate Bitcoin on a massive scale, transforming its identity from a traditional business software provider into a de facto cryptocurrency investment vehicle.

Analysts at JPMorgan estimate the potential fallout from an MSCI exclusion could force approximately $2.8 billion in sales by funds that track MSCI indexes. Should MSCI's action establish a new industry standard prompting other index providers like FTSE or S&P to follow, the total estimated outflows could reach as high as $8.8 billion.

The consultation period is open until December 31, 2025, with a final decision expected on January 15, 2026. Implementation within the indexes could follow as soon as February, creating a tight timeline for potential changes.

Bitcoin Gains Offset by Share Dilution

Despite the looming index threat, MicroStrategy shares advanced significantly on Friday. Support came from a stabilization in the price of Bitcoin, to which the company's fortunes are operationally and psychologically tethered. However, this positive momentum is being counteracted by a recent capital raise.

Earlier in the week, the firm disclosed the purchase of an additional 10,645 Bitcoins for roughly $980 million. This acquisition was financed through the issuance of new equity. The dilutive effect of this share sale is cited as a key reason the stock trades well below its 2024 highs, currently sitting approximately 65% under its 52-week peak. Shares closed Friday at €140.95, marking a weekly gain of 4.41% but a decline of 6.35% over a longer period.

Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Strategy?

Contrasting this pressure is an optimistic outlook for the underlying asset. Citigroup's base case scenario projects Bitcoin could reach $143,000 within the next twelve months. Given that MicroStrategy's valuation is heavily dependent on Bitcoin's price trajectory, this bullish forecast provided underlying support and likely contributed to the end-of-week share price increase.

Which Companies Are in the Crosshairs?

The MSCI review extends beyond MicroStrategy. It also names Bitcoin mining companies such as Riot and MARA Holdings, which are similarly classified as crypto-adjacent equities. In contrast, firms like Coinbase are considered more resilient to the proposed 50% threshold, as their own cryptocurrency holdings typically fall below this level.

MicroStrategy's exposure is particularly acute because its business model is intentionally built around the "Digital Asset Treasury" concept. The company uses both equity and debt to place Bitcoin on its balance sheet, thereby maximizing its leverage to crypto market cycles. While this structure has dramatically amplified shareholder returns during bull markets, it is now the very feature drawing scrutiny under potential new index rules.

Historical precedents for index exclusions typically show significant short-term volatility and reduced liquidity. Proponents of the MicroStrategy investment thesis argue that trading volume is already dominated by active, crypto-savvy investors, suggesting passive MSCI-driven flows may be less consequential over the long term. What is certain is that the market is already pricing in a premium for this new index risk, evidenced by the stock's increasing decoupling from pure Bitcoin price movements in recent weeks.

Looking Ahead: Two Key Dates to Watch

Two imminent dates are critical for investors. First, Bitcoin options worth approximately $23 billion are set to expire on December 26. This event could substantially increase volatility in the underlying asset around the holiday period, consequently magnifying price swings in MicroStrategy shares.

However, the more decisive factor for the medium to long-term outlook remains January 15, 2026. This is the date by which MSCI intends to announce its final decision on the proposed rule change. A hard exclusion of crypto proxies from its indexes would crystallize the anticipated billion-dollar outflows and likely create additional near-term selling pressure. Conversely, should MSCI retain its current methodology, it would serve as a significant relief signal for the stock.